With any iota of creativity comes a lack of warranty that that same creativity will produce good ideas. Whenever brainstorming sessions happen, whether they’re group efforts or individual “stare at a wall until you get an idea” moments, their facility to produce thought after thought is unquestionable.
What is questionable is whether those thoughts, or even some of those thoughts, should mature into full-blown ideas.
Through my years of making movies, from documentaries to comedy shorts to small dramatic pieces, I’ve never known if the idea I had for a given piece is good or not. What’s worse, for most pieces, you need to talk to lots of people in order to make it happen. You need to sell the idea to plausible actors, stage hands, camerapeople, boom operators; the works.
In essence, to see if the idea is worthy of execution, you need to sell it to people whilst unbeknownst to its appeal or feasibility. And that, I find, is the bane of any creator whose craft requires convincing others to follow through and along.
You’re always guaranteed that your purpose is pure as dictated by your own drive and passion for it, but when it comes to whether the drive and passion behind the idea is worhty of it, you’ve got nothing but a lack of warranty.